A full gym can still be an underpriced business. The question is not simply what nearby gyms charge. It is whether your membership prices support the service you deliver, the people delivering it and the owner doing the work.

Start with your own costs and capacity. Then use competitor prices as context, not instructions. This guide is a decision framework for independent gyms, CrossFit boxes and coaching studios. All dollar amounts in the worked example are illustrative Canadian dollars, before applicable sales tax. They are not MERGE prices, client results or industry benchmarks.

Start with the business your price must support

Separate three things before setting a rate:

  • The cost of delivering training: coaching, payroll-related costs, equipment upkeep and payment processing.
  • The cost of keeping the business open: rent, utilities, insurance, software and administration.
  • The return required from the business: compensation for the owner's work and a planned operating surplus.

Owner pay is not whatever happens to remain. If you coach classes or manage the business without recording the cost of that work, your price can appear sustainable only because you are subsidising it with unpaid labour. Read owner pay in Canadian gyms for the separate income question.

Avoid double-counting. If your own coaching compensation is already in payroll, do not add it again as a second cost. Separate compensation for work from profit attributable to ownership. An accountant can help map that distinction to your business structure.

A worked pricing floor, not a recommended membership rate

Imagine a single-program gym planning the following monthly figures:

ItemIllustrative amount
Operating costs, including paid coaching and administrationCA$24,000
Owner compensation for work not already counted aboveCA$4,000
Planned operating surplusCA$3,000
Total revenue requirementCA$31,000
Paying members expected on average155

CA$31,000 divided by 155 members is CA$200 per paying member per month.

That is an average revenue requirement, not automatically the advertised unlimited rate. Discounts, different membership tiers and payment failures can make collected revenue differ from the price on your website. Sales tax collected for remittance is not membership revenue in this calculation.

The example also assumes the CA$24,000 estimate includes expected payment fees and delivery costs at this membership level. If those costs change with volume, recalculate them for each scenario. A one-line division is a starting point, not a complete financial forecast.

If the same revenue requirement were spread over 140 members, the required average would be about CA$221.43. At 170, it would be about CA$182.35. Those figures do not mean more members always solve the problem. More members can require more classes, coaching and space.

Use your actual collected figures with the average revenue per member guide. Keep its measurement question separate from this guide's pricing decision.

Membership pricing calculator

Illustrative Canadian-dollar inputs, before sales tax. Adjust every figure to your gym.

Include coaching, rent, fees and administration at this membership level.

Only compensation not already included in costs.

A planning allowance, not a guaranteed profit.

A realistic average, not total leads or available spaces.

Sessions you can consistently deliver.

At your intended coaching quality.

Expected attendance across this program.

100% is a theoretical ceiling. Reduce for uneven demand and headroom.

Cost-based suggested average membership price

CA$200.00/ month
Monthly revenue requirement:
CA$31,000.00
Capacity-supported members:
160
Paying members used:
155

Revenue requirement = costs + separately counted owner pay + planned surplus. Divide by the lower of expected paying members and capacity-supported members. This is a planning starting point, not an optimised advertised rate. Check peak-time demand, plan mix, collections, variable costs and agreements separately.

Check the capacity you can actually sell

Count usable class spaces, not just floor area. Then examine when members want to train.

For illustration, 40 weekly classes with 12 spaces each provide 480 class spaces. At an average of three visits per member per week, 160 members would use all 480 spaces in aggregate. That is a theoretical ceiling under those assumptions, not a comfortable operating target.

The aggregate can hide the real constraint. Evening classes may be full while midday classes remain quiet. An unlimited member can also attend more than the average. Leave room for variation, new-member visits and the service experience you promise.

Ask:

  1. Which sessions repeatedly fill or create waitlists?
  2. How many additional visits could those sessions accept without reducing coaching quality?
  3. Would more members require extra classes or another coach?
  4. Could an off-peak option use genuinely available capacity without displacing full-price demand?

Do not solve a peak-time capacity problem by selling more cheap unlimited memberships. Price, scheduling and staffing need to agree with one another.

Compare membership options by what they cost to deliver

You do not need three tiers because a pricing article says so. You need options that make sense for your service and your members.

Limited-frequency group training can fit a predictable attendance commitment. State booking allowances, expiry and any additional-session price clearly.

Unlimited group training gives flexibility, but you must model actual attendance and peak-time demand. Unlimited access is not unlimited coaching capacity.

Small-group or individual coaching needs a separate cost calculation. More coach attention can justify a different price, but only if the time, preparation and delivery are accounted for.

For each option, write down the monthly price, expected visits, coaching time, restrictions and expected collected revenue. Ask whether a member can understand the difference without a sales explanation.

Use revenue per visit only as a diagnostic. A member who attends less often is not automatically a better customer, and attendance is relevant to retention. Do not improve a spreadsheet by making training harder to access.

Compare the market without copying it

Build a small comparison of gyms serving a similar customer and offering a similar coaching experience. Compare total costs and terms, not headline prices alone.

Look at coaching attention, class size, opening times, access limits, joining fees, contract term and applicable taxes. A budget access gym and a coached small-group studio are not interchangeable products.

If your calculated revenue requirement is higher than what your intended customer is willing to pay, investigate the mismatch. You may need a different service model, a lower cost base or a clearer offer. The answer is not automatically a more persuasive sales pitch.

Keep tax and contract decisions separate from pricing advice

Review the Canadian gym GST/HST guide and the CRA's registration guidance with your accountant. Registration obligations depend on your circumstances. Do not copy another gym's tax treatment.

In BC, Consumer Protection BC's fitness contract guidance explains required contract information and cancellation rights. Other provinces have their own rules. This article does not establish a right to change an existing member's price or prescribe a legally sufficient notice period.

Record what is included, what is charged separately and how the agreement works. Clear pricing should survive both the sales conversation and the first invoice.

Decide what changes first

Separate new-member pricing from existing agreements. A new advertised rate does not by itself change what an existing member owes.

If a rate change is needed, use the companion guide on raising gym membership prices. It covers scenario planning, contract checks and member communication without promising zero cancellations.

Before making a decision, build a one-page sheet with your revenue requirement, collected revenue by plan, realistic capacity and the assumptions most likely to change. Review it against the gym numbers scorecard.

Your next step: run Member Math

Run Member Math to explore your membership revenue under different retention and follow-up assumptions. It is not a pricing optimiser or a profit calculator: it does not model your rent, payroll or contract obligations.

Use it alongside the cost and capacity sheet above. A retention improvement may reduce the pressure to raise prices, but it does not make an undercosted service sustainable. Return to Numbers and Pricing for the supporting guides.

FREE GYM NUMBERS TEARDOWN

Twenty minutes with Dai on your own membership numbers.

Book a free teardown

Sources

  1. CRA: When to register for and start charging the GST/HST
  2. Consumer Protection BC: Fitness or personal services contracts, rules for businesses