Unlimited and limited memberships are different promises about access. Neither is automatically more profitable. The right comparison is what each plan collects, how much training members use and what it costs to deliver that training without weakening the experience.
Read Member Math: price increases, cancellations and gym revenue for the revenue and retention comparison. This guide adds the delivery side: class spaces, coaching costs and the difference between a session's contribution and the whole gym's profit.
All amounts, attendance patterns and costs below are illustrative Canadian-dollar examples, before applicable sales tax. They are not client results, recommended rates or industry benchmarks.
Compare the access promise before comparing the price
A limited plan might offer eight group sessions per calendar month. An unlimited plan might allow attendance at all eligible group sessions, subject to booking rules and available space. These are examples, not terms to copy into your agreements.
Specify booking allowances, eligible classes, expiry, pauses, cancellation terms and any additional-session charges. Eight sessions per month is not the same as two sessions every week. A member should not need to discover that difference on an invoice.
Unlimited access is not unlimited capacity. If popular sessions are repeatedly full, a more expensive unlimited plan can still create a service problem. A limited plan can also concentrate demand in exactly the same evening sessions.
Start with collected revenue per visit
For a simplified comparison, assume a limited plan collects CA$160 per month and its member uses eight sessions. Allocated membership revenue is CA$20 per visit. An unlimited plan collecting CA$220 with sixteen visits allocates CA$13.75 per visit.
| Illustrative plan | Monthly collected revenue | Monthly visits | Allocated revenue per visit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eight-session plan, all sessions used | CA$160 | 8 | CA$20.00 |
| Unlimited, twelve visits | CA$220 | 12 | CA$18.33 |
| Unlimited, sixteen visits | CA$220 | 16 | CA$13.75 |
| Unlimited, twenty visits | CA$220 | 20 | CA$11.00 |
That is a revenue allocation, not a separate fee earned every time someone enters class. In a membership business, most revenue arrives through the plan rather than a per-visit sale. Changing attendance changes this diagnostic without necessarily changing the money collected.
Do not conclude that members who train less are automatically better customers. The offer exists to deliver training. Attendance, satisfaction and retention belong in the same review, not outside it.
Estimate class contribution without calling it gym profit
Suppose a class has ten attending members: five limited-plan members allocated CA$20 each per visit and five unlimited members allocated CA$13.75 each. Allocated session revenue is CA$168.75.
Assume CA$60 in direct coaching cost and CA$8 in session-specific supplies and other direct delivery costs. Contribution after those listed direct costs is CA$100.75.
Class contribution = allocated class revenue - the direct class costs included in the calculation.
The ten people did not necessarily generate ten new payments that day. This is an allocation for comparing delivery, not a claim that cancelling the class would remove CA$168.75 of immediate cash revenue.
Nor is CA$100.75 the gym's profit. Rent, software, insurance, administration, owner work and other costs may remain unallocated. Define which costs are included before comparing classes. If processing fees or employment costs belong in the calculation, include them consistently rather than quietly excluding them.
For members attending several programs, allocate their collected membership revenue once across their included activity. Do not assign their entire monthly payment to every program they visit.
Model the whole gym with the same cost boundaries
Imagine 100 paying members and compare two membership mixes. For this example only, assume all limited members use eight monthly visits and all unlimited members use sixteen.
| Monthly scenario | Limited members at CA$160 | Unlimited members at CA$220 | Revenue | Member visits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mix A | 60 | 40 | CA$18,400 | 1,120 |
| Mix B | 30 | 70 | CA$20,200 | 1,360 |
Mix B collects CA$1,800 more but needs 240 more monthly visits. Whether that improves the business depends on where those visits fit and what extra delivery they require.
Assume the existing schedule provides 120 monthly classes at twelve spaces each, or 1,440 aggregate spaces. Average utilization is about 77.8% for Mix A and 94.4% for Mix B. Neither average establishes that a particular evening class has room.
For a simplified operating result, assume CA$60 of coaching cost per class, plus CA$10,000 of other monthly operating costs. The latter includes compensation for owner work not already counted in coaching. Those costs total CA$17,200 for the existing schedule.
Mix A then produces a CA$1,200 operating surplus. Mix B produces CA$3,000 if the same schedule and costs truly suffice. If Mix B requires 24 additional classes at CA$60 each, coaching costs rise by CA$1,440 and its surplus becomes CA$1,560, only CA$360 above Mix A.
These surplus figures are before financing costs, income tax and any expense omitted from the stated assumptions. They are not complete net-profit forecasts. If additional sessions require another manager, more cleaning or extra space, include those changes too. Consult your accountant on the business-wide profit measure you use.
Do not cut a class just because its allocation looks weak
A quiet class can serve members who cannot attend at another time. Removing it might save a coaching payment, but the allocation alone cannot tell you whether members will downgrade, cancel or move elsewhere.
Conversely, adding a class for demand that would comfortably fit the existing schedule can add cost without adding collected revenue. Ask which costs actually change, which members benefit and what the alternatives are.
If the existing coach is on a fixed salary and their paid hours do not change, removing one class may not save the allocated coaching cost immediately. Distinguish an accounting allocation from an avoidable cash expense.
Build a membership worksheet, not a universal winner
For each plan, record:
- Actual collected monthly revenue, including discounts and failed collections but excluding sales tax collected for remittance.
- Members, visits and the distribution of visits by day and time.
- Booking limits, waitlists, late cancellations and unmet demand.
- Direct coaching costs, including preparation and employment costs where applicable.
- Business-wide operating costs and separately counted owner compensation.
- Cancellations, downgrades and pauses by plan and original member cohort.
Then compare a few mixes while holding prices and attendance assumptions explicit. Model spare capacity and extra-class scenarios separately. Do not sell more unlimited access on the assumption that unused midday spaces solve a full evening schedule.
Use the gym pricing strategy guide to connect this sheet to your revenue requirement. If existing rates or access terms will change, follow the price-increase guide and check the actual agreements and applicable requirements before acting.
Bring retention back into the decision
A plan that looks profitable for one month may perform differently if people leave, downgrade or stop finding sessions that fit their lives. A higher unlimited rate does not guarantee fewer cancellations. A cheaper limited plan does not guarantee longer retention.
Run Member Math to explore membership revenue under retention and follow-up assumptions. It does not model class attendance, plan-specific delivery costs or gym profit. For a mixed membership base, review each plan in your worksheet rather than relying only on one blended dues figure.
The Member Math article explains why a one-time departure and ongoing churn need separate scenarios. Use that revenue view alongside this delivery-cost view, then return to Numbers and Pricing for the supporting guides.
FREE GYM NUMBERS TEARDOWN
Twenty minutes with Dai on your own membership numbers.
Book a free teardown
